Thread:Cheese Ausar/@comment-24398846-20140408193848/@comment-10427184-20140412003554

Muzic Beaner wrote: Cheese Ausar wrote: Also, you said this: "The main function of the "EDIT" feature is to ADD info and REVISE spelling, grammar mistakes and OCCACIONALY remove info when its appropriate, and by that I mean info that is plainly wrong."

Well, I get your point, and yes, information that is plainly wrong should be removed.

However, it is not wrong when I delete stuff. The function of editing is to both add stuff and delete stuff as the user sees fit, as long as it does not break the rules of the wiki. There's no rule that says deleting info is wrong (unless it's obvious vandalism).

Well, we're talking about the repair bot'' here, not Ketar. Any information about the company should go to the Ketar page, right?'' Let me address this in order as to not loose track.

REVISING:  Yes, adding, editing, removal of information is all good in moderation and under good judgment and for good reason. However, I've noticed many of your revisions to be simply  removal  of information based on your own personal opinion of whether the info is accurate or not or if it belongs there. Unfortunately we can't really remove someone else's contribution to a page based off our personal opinion of agreeing with it or not. Yes, you are right there is no stated rule regarding this, but this lies further than a simple rule, its wiki etiquette. Remember that this wiki is a COLABORATION of information by contributing Wikians who may or may not share your same opinions, and to remove someone else's informational contribution based on whether we agree on it or not its not correct. Like I sated previously, the only circumstance under which I see fit to completely remove someone else's contribution is for example something like ''' "Trivia: *The Specter is of Nivelian origin but built by Terran Contractors." ''' That obviously is a false piece of information and I would be one to delete it. But case in point, I just don’t think its right we modify pages to "our liking" based on difference of opinion over the INFO and not factual reasoning.



KETAR REPAIR BOT II:  Ketar   and  Rapair Bot II  are two in one. Hence the name KETAR REPAIR BOT II. You're trying to separate one whole product into its firm. Yes KETAR is a repair bot manufacturing firm and there is a page for it, but in this case its talking about one of its specific products, which carries the name of the firm in its name, so addressing it by KETAR Repair Bot II by no means strayes from the topic.



All this is MY PERSONAL opinion, and its openly subject to review and clarification by others if necessary.

  ~Muzic Beaner~ 16:29, April 11, 2014 (UTC)

KETAR is the company, not the REPAIR BOT. It bears the same name, but that doesn't mean stuff from Ketar goes there. Ketar Repair Bot II is also a completely new bot, with different textures and stats. Therefore, it doesn't improve on its predecessor's stats, in which case it would be a sort of software or something.

The stuff I removed (remember, there's nothing wrong about that) was mainly comparisons with other ships; why'd you need a comparison? The user reading that page can just check out the stats and make a comparison based on his own opinion, in which case the page is not doing.

Every user here has prominence, and they are free to edit what they want, unless it breaks the rules.